Negotiating Rebates: Best Practices
PurchTips - Edition # 182 July 14, 2009
By Charles Dominick, SPSM
Should Negotiating Rebates Be A Priority?
Some procurement professionals like to demonstrate that they've negotiated concessions on every last term in order to impress their management. Obviously, being tenacious and effective is indeed admirable. But there are pros and cons to negotiating rebates.
There are a few reasons I have preferred to have the rebates factored into a lower price rather than waiting until the end of the year to capture them. First, there's always a risk that the rebates won't be paid or remembered. Second, there's a risk that the price will be inflated in order to cover a rebate to be paid later. That can make it easier for internal customers to find that "deal that's better than Procurement gets" - never good politically! Third, there is the time value of money and corporate cash flow improvement initiatives that make money more attractive to have now rather than later.
However, there are times when negotiating rebates is appropriate. One such time is when you lack a reliable quantity forecast. In one situation with a prior employer, we had a reliable forecast for a large quantity of goods in one category (Category A) but weren't sure how many (if any) purchases of a second category (Category B) we would make from the same supplier.
Of course, I negotiated a low, low price for Category A. Then I negotiated a volume-based rebate on Category B that allowed us to take advantage of discounts if we deserved them without committing to a quantity that we couldn't guarantee. This was a win for the supplier as well, because we didn't require them to honor a price based on a volume that we didn't end up meeting.
So, for example, if we ended up buying 0-10, we got a 0% rebate. If we ended up buying 11-20, we got a 1% rebate. If we ended up buying 21-30, we got a 2% rebate, and so on.
A final, important note on rebates: It is important for rebates to be distributed to the end users' cost centers, not the "general fund" or Procurement's budget (unless that's how top management wants it). Rebates distributed outside of the end users' cost centers can cause internal customers to feel that their budgets are being stolen from and will cause them to distrust Procurement.
(keep reading for a FREE Offer)
Spotlight On Professional Development Opportunities
In purchasing, there is the top talent and there is everyone else. In which category do you belong?
As a purchasing professional, people are always trying to figure out your talent level. Whether it's a current employer deciding who to lay off in a bad economy, a company seeking to hire a new purchasing manager, or even a supplier trying to determine the capabilities of his negotiating counterpart, people are always evaluating whether purchasers are true professionals or just "average buyers."
Sure, most purchasing professionals will feel that they are among the elite, but how can you prove that you are? Earning the SPSM® Certification is a powerful way to confirm and communicate that you are among the most talented purchasing professionalsin the world. And with the recent launch of the higher-level SPSM2 Certification, the gap between the best and the rest is getting wider. The best keep up with the profession.
Can you afford to be perceived as someone that is letting the profession pass you by? If not, learn how to earn your SPSM® (and perhaps get an iPod Touch) at:
The Latest Purchasing News
- Discuss today's topic on our LinkedIn SPSM Group! Visit www.tinyurl.com/7lmbzy
- Not a member of the LinkedIn SPSM Group? Learn how to join at: www.tinyurl.com/8tgfnd
- Considering a career move? Browse jobs preferring candidates with the SPSM® Certification at: www.NextLevelPurchasing.com/jobs
Purchasing Leaders: What are the secrets to having a successful team? This question is answered by our FREE whitepaper "The Purchasing Leader's Guide To A More Successful Team."