How To Debrief Unsuccessful Bidders
PurchTips - Edition # 38 December 16, 2003
By Charles Dominick
How Should You Explain Your Purchase Decision?
The purchasing and supply management function plays an important role in developing an organization's image. Purchasing, together with sales, is responsible for most of an organization's contacts with the business community.
The manner in which the competitive bidding process is managed is probably the most significant factor in shaping how the supply base views the organization. So, for the preservation of your organization's positive image, you should treat the competitive bidding process with care. One facet of the process that is of particular significance is the debriefing procedure.
Debriefing is simply the act of meeting with an unsuccessful bidder to explain why their bid was not deemed to be the most attractive. Debriefing is a fragile process. You want to be as helpful as possible to the unsuccessful bidder, but you also must maintain the confidentiality of other suppliers' information. Here are a few guidelines for conducting debriefings:
State your debriefing goals in writing, both internally and to the bidder. Goals may include: identifying weaknesses in the bidder's proposal, demonstrating that the bidder was treated fairly, promoting good relations within the business community, answering the bidder's questions, and obtaining feedback from the bidder.
Provide helpful information to the bidder. Helpful information includes: strengths of the bidder's proposal, weaknesses of the bidder's proposal, and the reasons for not accepting the bidder's proposal.
Protect confidential information. This type of information includes the names of other bidders, the ranking of other bidders, and the specifics of the other bidders' proposals (such as price or the dollar amount or percentage difference between the winning proposal and the bidder's proposal).
Well-done debriefings can reinforce a positive reputation for your organization. By following and expanding upon these guidelines, you can help your organization secure an identity of fairness, integrity, and professionalism.
Spotlight On Professional Development Opportunities
Are you putting your organization at significant risk by not having a good contract in place? Without contract writing skills, you may be contributing to a disaster waiting to happen. Next Level Purchasing's online class "Supply Management Contract Writing" will help you reduce your procurement risks. This class goes beyond explaining contract law. Through plain English examples and exercises, you will learn how to negotiate and write effective contracts and terms
For more information on this and other online classes for purchasing professionals, visit:
There are four irreversible business and technology trends that are likely to cost purchasers like you their jobs in the next 12 months. Do you know what they are? Do you know how to protect yourself from their effects? If not, you should get your FREE report entitled "Career Survival In Supply Management."
"Career Survival In Supply Management" describes these four trends and how they are steadily decreasing the number of purchasing jobs in today's volatile global economy. It then gives you a seven-step process to stay in the game under the new rules. If you want to remain in the purchasing profession for years to come, you owe it to yourself to check out this report!
"Career Survival In Supply Management,"follow the instructions at